Online vs. In-Store Returns: What's Actually Different?

Returning an item shouldn't be complicated, but somehow it often is. Whether you're dealing with that sweater that looked better online or shoes that just don't fit right, knowing your return options can save you time, money, and hassle.

Let's break down the real differences between online and in-store returns so you can choose the method that works best for you.

Table of Contents

• Online Returns: Maximum Convenience
• In-Store Returns: Speed When You Need It
• The Timeline: When Will You Actually Get Your Money Back?
• Which Return Method Should You Choose?
• Frequently Asked Questions

Online Returns: Maximum Convenience

Online returns have become the default choice for many shoppers. Just print a label, drop off your package, and you're done. But is it always the best option?

The Benefits

You don't have to leave your house. This is the biggest advantage. No driving to the store, no waiting in line, no rearranging your schedule. Just pack up the item and drop it at your doorstep or nearest collection point.

Perfect for busy schedules. If you work during store hours or simply don't have time to make a special trip, online returns let you handle everything on your own time.

Usually free. Most major retailers now offer free return shipping with prepaid labels, so you won't have to pay out of pocket to send items back.

Simple and trackable. Modern return portals make the process straightforward. Initiate your return with a few clicks, print your label, and track your return status so you know exactly where your refund stands.

The Drawbacks

The waiting game. This is where online returns lose their appeal. Processing times can stretch out for days or even weeks, leaving you wondering when you'll actually see your money back in your account.

Surprise fees. That "free return" might come with a restocking fee, especially for electronics, large items, or opened products. These fees can add up quickly and eat into your refund.

No chance to reconsider. Once you've sealed the box and dropped it off, there's no turning back. You can't inspect the item one more time or decide whether you actually want to keep it after all.

High return rates mean stricter policies. Because online purchases see return rates between 15% and 40%, with an estimated 19.3% of online sales returned in 2025, some retailers are getting stricter with their policies or charging return fees to offset costs.

In-Store Returns: Speed When You Need It

In-store returns offer a completely different experience. You bring the item back to the store and handle everything face-to-face.

The Benefits

Get your money back immediately. This is the biggest win. Walk in with your item, complete the return, and your refund or exchange is processed on the spot. No waiting, no wondering.

No extra fees. You often won't get hit with restocking fees or return shipping charges when you return items in person.

See it one more time. Before finalizing your return, you can inspect the item again, try it on one more time, or check sizing to make sure you're making the right decision.

Easy exchanges. If you want a different size or color, you can often swap items right there without waiting for a refund to process first.

The Drawbacks

It takes effort. You have to drive to the store, find parking, potentially wait in line, and complete paperwork. If the store is far from your home or work, this can be a real hassle.

Not all stores accept returns. Some retailers don't allow in-store returns at all, or they have limited return windows for in-person returns. And, some retailers are online only. 

You might be limited to store credit. Instead of getting your money back, some stores only offer store credit or force you to do an exchange rather than a refund.

Store hours matter. If you work a 9-to-5 job and the store closes at 6 PM, finding time to make it there can be challenging.

The Timeline: When Will You Actually Get Your Money Back?

If you care about getting your refund quickly (and who doesn't?), the timeline matters.

In-store refunds are fast. When you return items in person, you typically get your money back immediately. Some refunds post to your account within minutes, others within a few business days, but stores may process most in-store returns right away. Of course, when your refund hits your account can also depend on your financial institution.

Online refunds take time. Your item needs to ship back to the warehouse, go through inspection, and then (finally) your refund gets processed. Each step adds days. You're often looking at 1-2 weeks, and sometimes longer during busy seasons.

Which Return Method Should You Choose?

Here's the reality: according to a study by the National Retail Federation, 82% of shoppers consider free returns to be important when deciding whether to shop online or not. The best retailers give you both options and let you choose.

Choose online returns when:

• Convenience is your top priority
• You don't mind waiting for your refund
• The store is far from your home or work 
• You're returning during off-hours when stores are closed

Choose in-store returns when:

• You need your money back fast
• You want to avoid potential fees
• You want to inspect the item one more time
• You're considering an exchange instead of a refund

Either way, you shouldn't have to choose between convenience and speed. The best shopping experiences give you flexible options and let you return products in whatever way works best for your situation.

If retailers are lacking transparency, tools can help. Refundly is a free app in the App Store that securely connects to your email and bank or credit card accounts to track all your returns in one place. It alerts you the moment your refund hits your account. No more constantly checking whether the money has arrived. For more details, check out the Refundly website.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between online and in-store returns?

Online returns let you ship items back from home, while in-store returns require you to bring items to a physical location. Online returns are more convenient but take longer to process, while in-store returns are faster but require more effort.

Are online returns faster than in-store returns?

No, in-store returns are much faster. You typically get your refund immediately when returning in person, while online returns can take 1-2 weeks or longer for the item to ship back and your refund to process. Amazon says to allow for up to 30 days to get your refund back in your account. 

Do I have to pay to return items online?

It depends on the retailer. Many offer free return shipping with prepaid labels, but some charge return shipping fees or restocking fees. Always check the return policy before making your purchase.

Can I return an online purchase in store?

Many retailers offer buy-online-return-in-store options, letting you return online purchases at their physical locations. This gives you the convenience of online shopping with the speed of in-store refunds. Check the retailer's specific policy to confirm.

Will I get charged a restocking fee for my return?

It depends on the item and retailer. Electronics, large appliances, and opened items often have restocking fees, which can range from 10-25% of the purchase price. Check the return policy for specific items before returning.

What if I lost my receipt?

Many retailers can look up your purchase using your credit card, email, or loyalty account. Some will still accept returns without a receipt but may only offer store credit instead of a refund. In-store returns without receipts are usually easier to process than online returns.

‍